The Kansas City Chiefs’ 22–19 loss to the Denver Broncos in Week 11 was painful enough for a team fighting to regain control of the AFC West. But what happened after the game created an even bigger storm — one that centered not on Patrick Mahomes, not on the defense, but on veteran kicker Harrison Butker.

In a stunning postgame segment on ESPN’s national broadcast, Hall of Famer Troy Aikman unloaded on Butker, calling his missed extra point — the one that kept Kansas City from taking a five-point lead — “a catastrophic mistake from a player who should know better.” Aikman went even further, adding:
“These are the moments you get paid for. Special teams cannot be the reason you lose a divisional game. That kick was unacceptable at this level.”
The comment exploded online within minutes. Chiefs fans were already frustrated after the blocked PAT shifted the game’s momentum and set up Denver’s game-winning drive. Aikman’s words poured gasoline on a fire that was already burning.
Across social media, the criticism turned brutal:

“Cut him tomorrow.”

“Butker cost us the game.”

“This is the worst special-teams showing in years.”

But inside the Chiefs’ locker room, the tone was very different.
Head coach Andy Reid stepped to the podium moments later and delivered one of the strongest public defenses of a player in his career.
“Harrison Butker is one of the toughest competitors I’ve ever coached,” Reid said firmly. “We win a lot of games in this league because of him. One kick will never define his worth to this team. And let me be crystal clear — if anyone has the right to criticize him, that person is me. No one else.”

Reporters noted Reid’s unusually sharp tone, a clear message that he believed the criticism had crossed a line. Teammates echoed the sentiment, insisting Butker’s work ethic and consistency remain elite. Several veterans said the blocked kick came from a breakdown in protection, not from Butker’s technique.
Still, Aikman’s words sparked national debate. Was the legendary quarterback simply being honest about a costly error, or was his criticism unfairly placed on a player who has been one of the most reliable kickers in the NFL for years?

Chiefs insiders pointed out that despite the blocked PAT, Butker remains near the top of the league in field-goal accuracy. And more importantly, the Chiefs’ loss stemmed from several deeper issues — including four special-teams penalties, a 70-yard Broncos punt return, and a defense that allowed Denver to control the final minutes.Butker himself did not fire back. He simply told reporters:
“My job is to put the ball through the uprights. If I don’t do that, I take it personally. But I’ll be ready next week.”
The Chiefs’ locker room reportedly rallied around their kicker, with Mahomes and Travis Kelce both offering quiet words of support.
As for Aikman, his comments continue to trend across every major sports platform. But inside Kansas City, the message from their head coach was clear, unshakeable, and direct:
“Harrison Butker doesn’t run from adversity. He meets it. And so do we.”
If Kansas City manages to bounce back in Week 12, this moment — the criticism, the defense, the unity — may become the spark that shifted their season back on track.