NFL Officially Rejects Giants Coach’s Lawsuit After Reviewing Game Footage — League Confirms Zack Baun–Cam Skattebo Collision Was Legal and Original Decision Fully Correct.
The NFL has officially closed the investigation into one of Week 8’s most controversial moments — the collision between Philadelphia Eagles linebacker Zack Baun and New York Giants rookie running back Cam Skattebo. The league’s final verdict came after a thorough review of the game footage, rejecting the Giants coach’s lawsuit and declaring the play to be completely legal under NFL rules.
The incident occurred during the second quarter of the Eagles–Giants matchup when Baun tackled Skattebo near the sideline, resulting in a serious leg injury for the young running back. The moment drew outrage from fans and analysts, many of whom accused Baun of using a “hip-drop tackle,” a move widely debated for its safety risks. The Giants coach immediately filed an official complaint with the NFL, demanding disciplinary action.
However, after an extensive review process, league officials determined that Zack Baun’s tackle was within the boundaries of fair play. In a statement released Wednesday, the NFL said there was “no evidence of intent to injure or violation of safety protocol,” describing the event as “an unfortunate but clean football play.” The decision brought clarity but also reignited discussions about player safety and the evolving interpretation of defensive rules.
NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell addressed the ruling in a press conference later that day, saying, “We’ve reviewed every angle, slowed down every frame, and consulted with experts on the rules. The collision between Zack Baun and Cam Skattebo was an unfortunate moment, but fully legal within league regulations. Our priority remains player safety — but fairness must also guide our judgment.”
This is awful– Giants standout rookie RB Cam Skattebo just suffered an ankle injury, and it’s bad… pic.twitter.com/sXbr0HwCPx
— Arye Pulli (@AryePulliNFL) October 26, 2025
Following the ruling, Zack Baun spoke briefly to reporters, expressing relief and empathy toward Skattebo. “Football is a tough game, and no one wants to see a young player get hurt,” Baun said. “I respect Cam and everything he brings to the game. I never intended to harm anyone — I was just playing fast and doing my job.” His composure and professionalism have earned him praise from fans and teammates alike.
Meanwhile, the Giants organization has decided not to pursue further legal action following the NFL’s clarification. While disappointment lingers among supporters, the decision has been largely accepted as definitive. Some Giants players have spoken about moving forward, focusing on recovery and the remainder of the season rather than continuing the dispute.
Skattebo’s family, particularly his mother, publicly expressed forgiveness toward Baun, softening tensions between the two sides. “Cam knows this is part of the game,” she shared on social media. “We appreciate the support and prayers, and we hold no hard feelings. Accidents happen, but respect remains.” The post received thousands of supportive comments from fans across both franchises.
With the controversy now settled, attention turns back to the field. The Philadelphia Eagles continue their strong campaign, while the Giants regroup for the next matchup. For Zack Baun, the league’s ruling marks closure on a difficult chapter — and for the NFL, it stands as another test in balancing the sport’s physical nature with its ever-growing emphasis on safety and integrity.
