The Detroit Lions’ rapid rise under GM Brad Holmes has been one of the league’s most celebrated front-office success stories, but December 2025 has brought something new — the sharpest criticism Holmes has faced since taking over the franchise. His once-universally praised roster-building strategy is now under intense scrutiny as Detroit risks watching a playoff berth slip through its fingers following a string of injuries, depth collapses, and a free agency period many fans now believe was dangerously passive.

Holmes’ track record in the draft is extraordinary. His 2022 and 2023 classes produced franchise pillars such as Aidan Hutchinson, Jameson Williams, Terrion Arnold, Sam LaPorta, Jahmyr Gibbs, and Brian Branch. But for all the brilliance he’s displayed in the draft room, Holmes’ approach to free agency — cautious, conservative, and almost exclusively internal — is being questioned in ways that would’ve felt unthinkable just one year ago. Instead of aggressively upgrading the roster during a pivotal window of NFC contention, Holmes opted for minimal moves while division rivals, especially the Packers and Bears, made bold acquisitions that immediately changed the competitive balance.

The point of greatest frustration stems from the offensive line crisis. The Lions entered 2025 with an aging core group and no clear contingency plan. When Frank Ragnow retired in June and Taylor Decker battled lingering injuries, Detroit was left scrambling. Free agency had offered high-level solutions — most notably Falcons center Drew Dalman, a two-year starter whom Ben Johnson and the Bears secured for three years and $42 million. Instead, Holmes redirected Detroit’s resources toward defense, signing CB D.J. Reed and depth pieces rather than reinforcements in the trenches. That decision is now being viewed as a turning point.

Holmes defended his strategy earlier this week, telling reporters:
“We built this roster for sustainable success, not short-term panic. But I hear the criticism. I understand the frustrations. And ultimately, the responsibility falls on me.”
The quote spread quickly across Detroit media — some lauding Holmes for accountability, others viewing it as too little, too late. With the Lions’ offensive line now one of the league’s most battered units, many fans fear those words may end up being the epitaph of a season that began with Super Bowl hopes.

Evidence supporting those fears continues to pile up. Without Ragnow, and after letting veteran Kevin Zeitler walk in free agency, the Lions have relied on rookies, backups, and practice-squad players to protect Jared Goff and open lanes for Gibbs and David Montgomery. The results have been damaging: an offense that once looked explosive is now inconsistent, turnover-prone, and unable to control the line of scrimmage. Detroit has fallen from a top-10 offense in 2024 to the middle of the pack in 2025, with pass protection collapsing and interior pressure disrupting every phase of the playbook.

Meanwhile, the Bears — now 9–3 and leading the NFC North — have demonstrated exactly what an aggressive free agency approach can do. Johnson added Dalman, Pro Bowl guard Joe Thuney, and former Lion Jonah Jackson, transforming Chicago’s offensive line into one of the NFC’s strongest units. Their run game has exploded. Their rookie quarterback has stabilized. And the Bears — who trailed Detroit just a season ago — have taken control of the division. Packers GM Brian Gutekunst made a similarly aggressive move, acquiring Micah Parsons in a blockbuster trade that immediately elevated Green Bay’s defense to championship-caliber territory.

Detroit, by contrast, is fighting to stay afloat. At 7–5, with five games remaining, the Lions no longer control their own playoff destiny. They will likely need to win out and hope other NFC contenders stumble. Even then, the offensive line must perform at a level it has not shown all season — or Detroit may find itself watching the playoffs from home just one year after a historic NFC Championship appearance.

All of which brings the spotlight back to Holmes. The GM who rebuilt this roster is now the GM fans are begging to act with urgency — demanding he acknowledge that conservative free agency decisions, especially along the offensive line, have directly contributed to Detroit’s precarious situation. The calls are growing louder across social media, talk radio, and even within alumni circles: Detroit needs aggressiveness, not patience. Boldness, not bargain hunting. Action, not hindsight.

The Lions still have time to salvage the season, but their path is narrow and unforgiving. Whether they survive it may depend on whether the foundation Holmes built can withstand the pressure — or whether Detroit is forced to confront the consequences of an offseason where the GM stayed quiet while the rest of the division roared.